We have a fast-food salad and a shattered tooth to thank for the striking cover art of Poison the Well’s highly anticipated new album, PEACE IN PLACE — the Floridian-formed metalcore group’s first full-length collection since 2009.
As vocalist Jeff Moreira explains to Revolver, the artwork’s gnarly close-up of cracked molars and jagged incisors is actually a mold of his own chompers. On a call from his current home in Omaha, he tells us about how, around decade ago, a green and leafy meal went horribly awry when a bite left him with a broken back molar. He confesses, “This is the stupidest shit ever: I was eating a Wendy’s salad, and I swear there was a rock in it… I guess I bite pretty hard!”
Dumb as it was, the incident had a devastating effect. The vocalist — who spent much of his 2025 revisiting Poison the Well’s melodic, yet monstrously chugged-down 1999 debut album, The Opposite of December… A Season of Separation, on a 25th anniversary tour — says he then lived through “one of the most painful times” in his life for about a year, the exposed nerve amplifying every sensation. He doubled over in pain some days.
When he finally got the tooth fixed, he kept a plaster mold of his mouth as a memento. Years later, the singer became transfixed with the dental cast. As he stared at his imperfectly preserved smile, he began to think of the model as the perfect metaphor for his band’s long-awaited new album.
“It was really the first time that I had seen that part of my body. That mold showed me a part of me that I could never actually see,” he says. “I can stand up to a mirror and pull my gums back and try to look back that far into my mouth, but you’re not going to get a good view of it. It’s not like sitting there with the mold, [where] you can see every crack at every angle of that tooth… I felt like the teeth ended up being like this symbol for what the record could be.”
Speaking of PEACE IN PLACE, he puts it succinctly: “This record is the teeth that I get to leave behind.”’
The first taste of the album is teeth-baring first single “Thoroughbreds,” which, Moreira acknowledges, is a particularly heavy and angry introduction to PEACE IN PLACE. The tune gallops out the gate with propulsive riffery and a punitive, D-beating pace. Moreira screams his way through thoughts on faded monuments and mutually-assured erasure (“My voice kills yours/Your voice kills mine”). The singer, now 44, explains that the song is informed by the ways some of the friendships of his youth have eroded; its song title alludes to his high school’s horse mascot.
“I always thought that we would be friends for the rest of our lives,” Moreira reflects. “Just because we had made it so long, [I was] like, ‘These people will be a part of my life for the remainder of it, because our bonds are so strong, and we’ve been able to overcome so much stuff throughout the years.’ That actually never happened… Some of my closest friendships that I’ve had for a large part of my life have evaporated in sad ways. A lot of the times I would be like, ‘This seems really stupid that we no longer have a relationship.’ That’s what this song is about.”
What’s compelling about the theme, however, is how it runs counter to the way Poison the Well came back together to make PEACE IN PLACE. Not that it was easy: It took some time before the band members were willing to take a full-length plunge.
Founded in Miami, Florida, by lead guitarist Ryan Primack and drummer Chris Hornbrook in 1997, Poison the Well caught fire on their initial run when the band dropped The Opposite of December in late 1999. Moreira landed in the lineup shortly before they made the album, which has since become a much-loved staple of turn-of-the-century metalcore, its nine songs infusing aching melody with hulking riffs and health-hazardous breakdowns.
They’d go on to make four more albums and tour heavily over the next decade, but during the cycle behind 2009’s The Tropic Rot, Moreira started to tire of the road. Looking back now, he recalls the wear and tear of release cycles and the drain that both industry and fan expectations put on their creativity. Poison the Well wound things down in 2010, with Moreira generally resuming civilian life. They’ve reunited occasionally from 2014 onwards.
Moreira says that the core of he, Primack and Hornbrook have been talking about writing new music for years. The idea picked up steam in 2023 when they released an acoustic revamp of “Horns and Tails,” originally off 2002’s Tear From the Red. That subtly-strummed, sweetly-sung reimagining gave them confidence to push forward with new Poison the Well material, eventually birthing the hard-hammering “Trembling Level” single they released in early 2025 — a song that meta-textually nodded to the internal panic of dropping your first new song in more than a decade.
Poison the Well — which also currently includes guitarist Vadim Taver and bassist Noah Harmon — started playing that song live last spring, during the 25th anniversary tour for The Opposite of December. The North American portion of the trek found them supported by Better Lovers, the supergroup featuring former members of Every Time I Die and the Dillinger Escape Plan, as well as Fit for an Autopsy guitarist and future PEACE IN PLACE producer Will Putney.
While Better Lovers are a relatively new band, Moreira confirms he’d connected with its members through the hardcore scene years before, when Poison the Well would frequently cross paths with Every Time I Die and Dillinger Escape Plan. Those friendships endure — Moreira and his wife even hosted a Thanksgiving dinner for Better Lovers when they rolled through Omaha in November.
Though Moreira once felt conflicted about the touring life, he does have fondness for the way things were on the road back in the late Nineties: the lack of cell phones, cramming yourselves and your gear into a tiny rental van, the thrill of playing a sweaty basement show. Much had changed between Poison the Well’s early days and last year’s December tour, but the crowd energy at every stop still gave Moreira and his bandmates plenty of perspective and meaning.
“It definitely reminded me why I love Poison the Well so much,” he says. “I guess all the excitement that everybody has for these records that we wrote so long ago makes me feel extremely lucky that we are even able to do it. It made me feel like a complainer to even think, ‘Can I be on tour?’ Not everybody gets to do this, and not everybody gets to do this again.”
As Poison the Well began writing music for PEACE IN PLACE, the metalcore veterans knew they had to bring certain pieces to the table, Moreira notes. The intent was to “sound the heaviest and the prettiest that we’ve ever sounded.”
“For me, it had been a really long time since we had a double-kick part, or a straight-up breakdown,” he says of his personal wish list, “I love barbarian, caveman shit, you know? I really missed that. [Those were] some of the things that I was really looking for on this record.”
Album standouts like “Primal Bloom” sated Moreira’s caveman urges through bleakly hummable menace and thunderous, single-note stomp-outs. Album opener “Wax Mask” packs big screams, heavy groove and decadently discordant mosh riffs. At times, “Everything Hurts” crushes similarly, but Moreira’s weary, minors-driven vocal melodicism in the chorus explores the darkest recess of Nineties alt rock, while Primack’s weeping slide guitar — an aesthetic call back to his playing on 2007’s Versions — caps the track with Western cinematic sadness.
“We always try to incorporate the things that influence us, and that tends to be things that have nothing to do with heavy music — you know, old-school country, or [composer] Ennio Morricone,” Moreira explains, adding, “I listen to a lot of movie soundtracks at home. I’ll have horror movie soundtracks from the Seventies or the Eighties playing [in the background]. I think that shows up in that piece, specifically.”
When asked if, like that smashed molar, PEACE IN PLACE is the most exposed Poison the Well have been on a record, Moreira’s not so sure that’s the case. He hopes he and his bandmates have always been this raw with their presentation. “Ryan playing his guitar and coming up with riffs? That’s him exposing himself,” he says. “Anything I’ve ever written about is something that I care about, or that has affected me.”
Despite the sad and angry attack of first single “Thoroughbreds,” the lyrical tone fluctuates on PEACE IN PLACE as much as the sonics. Yes, there are songs about fractured friendships, but the vocalist hints at the band sneaking a love song onto the album, too. And when it comes to Poison the Well, this latest stage reinforces that Moreira is smitten with his writing partners.
“I love playing music,” the frontman confides. “I love writing with Ryan and Chris, and the ability to be able to do that makes me so happy. I would love to chase that as long as I can — as long as anybody’s willing to listen, and as long as we’re excited about doing it.
“What I’m trying to say is: If this is what the rest of my life is going to be like, I would say that that’s very peaceful.”
Order Revolver’s exclusive “solid gold” vinyl variant of PEACE IN PLACE, limited to 500, at our shop.